[Alpha Biz= Kim Jisun] A South Korean court has once again ruled in favor of a global tech company in a tax dispute, following similar decisions involving Netflix and Meta Platforms, raising calls for a broader overhaul of the taxation framework for foreign digital platforms.

On May 7, the Seoul High Court ruled partially in favor of Google Korea in a lawsuit seeking to cancel corporate tax and related assessments imposed by local tax authorities.

The court dismissed a separate claim against the Gangnam District Office regarding local tax collection, stating that since local taxes are linked to corporate tax, there was no practical benefit in pursuing a separate case.

The dispute dates back to 2020, when tax authorities imposed approximately KRW 154 billion in corporate and local income taxes on Google Korea. The authorities argued that payments sent to its Singapore-based affiliate, Google Asia Pacific—which oversees operations across the Asia-Pacific region—constituted royalty income subject to domestic taxation.

Google Korea, however, maintained that the payments should be classified as business income of the Singapore entity and therefore not taxable in Korea due to the absence of a permanent establishment.

Both the lower court and the appellate court sided with Google, ruling that the payments could not be clearly interpreted as compensation for intellectual property or know-how.

The ruling adds to a growing list of setbacks for tax authorities in cases involving global platforms. Previously, Netflix Korea successfully challenged approximately KRW 68.7 billion of a KRW 76.2 billion tax assessment, while Meta also won a case involving around KRW 200 billion in corporate taxes.

Industry observers say the latest decision underscores the structural challenges of taxing global platform companies that operate primarily through digital services and intangible assets. Under current international tax rules, key issues include whether a foreign company has a permanent establishment in Korea and how to classify income as royalties versus business profits—areas where courts have increasingly sided with tech firms.

The ruling is expected to accelerate discussions on introducing digital taxes and reforming cross-border taxation frameworks through international cooperation.

 

 

[ⓒ 알파경제. 무단전재-재배포 금지]